← All articles

A. Government Bill of the Federal Government

On 7 October 2026, the Federal Government adopted a new draft of an Act against digital violence (digitale Gewalt). The purpose of this Act is to close existing gaps in criminal liability and to adapt criminal law to technological developments.

Deepfakes and Voyeurism

Most users of social media or streaming platforms will probably already have heard of so-called deepfakes or have seen corresponding videos. Deepfakes are frequently created by the computer-aided generation of realistic-looking photographs and videos in which, for example, the face of a particular person is replaced. Various artificial intelligence techniques can be used for their creation. These include, among others, Generative Adversarial Networks (GANs). These frequently operate in combination with a discriminator that checks the authenticity of the desired result.1 Deepfakes are used not only for the dissemination of false information but also in pornographic contexts.2 These developments give cause for concern and raise, in particular, questions concerning the protection of the persons affected under criminal law.

Digital voyeurism comprises the secret observation or recording of other persons in situations that concern their intimate or private sphere. This takes place without their knowledge or consent and serves only the sexual interest of the observing persons. Corresponding recordings may then be disseminated in the digital space. The Federal Government intends to extend the protection under criminal law in these areas and to close existing regulatory gaps.3

Under the law currently in force, general offences come into consideration in such cases, in particular coercion under Section 240 of the German Criminal Code (Strafgesetzbuch, StGB) or threatening the commission of a serious criminal offence under Section 241 StGB. The offence of violation of intimate privacy and of rights of personality by taking photographs or other images under Section 201a StGB covers, among other things, the unauthorised creation or transmission of images of a person in private premises or in a room that is specially protected from view (Section 201a(1) no. 1 StGB) as well as images that exhibit the helplessness of another person (Section 201a(1) no. 2 StGB). The deliberate production of corresponding deepfake videos can therefore be subsumed under the existing offences of the StGB only in rare cases.

Sections 184 et seq. StGB criminalise, in particular, certain forms of dealing with pornographic content. In individual cases, not only its dissemination but also its production may be punishable. Section 184k StGB governs the violation of intimate parts of the body by taking photographs or other images. This also includes so-called “upskirting”.4

Overall, it becomes apparent that the criminal law currently in force already covers various forms of sexualised and image-based abuse. Artificially manipulated or generated images and video recordings do not necessarily fall under the corresponding offences. To that extent, gaps in protection under criminal law may exist.

New Criminal Offences

The envisaged amendments and new criminal offences are intended to extend the protection under criminal law in cases of digital violence. In doing so, the StGB is to be adapted in particular to technological developments that concern the creation and dissemination of manipulated content. Such content can have serious consequences for the private sphere of the persons affected.

First, Section 184k, which governs the protection of intimate parts of the body against photographs or other images, is to be comprehensively amended. The new provision is intended to extend the previous scope of application of the offence. In particular, it is intended to cover the unauthorised creation and making available of certain intimate image content and to extend the protection under criminal law to computer-generated or manipulated depictions as well.

Furthermore, the government bill provides for new provisions on the possession of certain particularly serious sexualised image content. Consequently, the unauthorised production of certain sexualised deepfakes is thereby also to be covered by criminal law.5

In addition, new offences are to be anchored in law. Provided for are, in particular, provisions on the violation of rights of personality by deceptive content under Section 201b StGB-E, the violation of rights of personality by a feigned identity under Section 201c StGB-E, and unauthorised surveillance by means of information or communication technology under Section 202e StGB-E (the suffix “-E” denoting the draft provisions, Entwurf).6 The rationale for criminalisation here lies in the possible considerable damage to the social reputation as well as to the personal self-determination and privacy of the persons affected.

In addition to the amendments to criminal law, the draft provides for the introduction of a separate Act against Digital Violence (Gesetz gegen digitale Gewalt, draft: GgdG-E). This is intended in particular to simplify the enforcement under civil law of claims in respect of digital infringements of rights. To this end, the judicial enforcement of measures against unlawful content, for instance on social networks, is to be facilitated. This also includes the temporary blocking of an account.7 This is permissible only where a court order has been issued. In doing so, the draft is based on the provisions of Union law and harmonises these requirements.

The envisaged amendments raise the question of their justification under constitutional law. Where a law is to be adopted, the draft must be examined for its compatibility with fundamental rights, European law provisions and other constitutional principles.

The German Federal Bar (Bundesrechtsanwaltskammer, BRAK) already voiced criticism of the then ministerial draft (Referentenentwurf) in May 2026. It welcomed the objective of the project but saw considerable need for improvement.8

A law and the provisions contained in it must satisfy the requirement of legal clarity (Bestimmtheitsgebot). The general requirement of legal clarity is derived from Article 20(3) of the Basic Law (Grundgesetz, GG). In the criminal-law context, reference must be made to the principle of specificity under Article 103(2) GG, under which the legislature is obliged to describe the conditions of criminal liability so specifically that the individual can know in advance what is prohibited.

The BRAK criticised that the mere production of deepfakes of adults, without any effect on the outside world (Außenwirkung), should not be criminalised prematurely. It considered a design as a concrete endangerment offence or one requiring an intention to disseminate to be conceivable. In the BRAK’s view, Section 184k StGB-E was in this respect too imprecise; in the draft version at the time, it had not been formulated with sufficient precision.

Compared with the draft status of 16 April 2026, the wording “in a sexually determined manner” (“in sexuell bestimmter Weise”) was replaced by the more specific description “in a manner that shapes the image and manifestly aims at depicting these parts of the body in a sexualised way” (“in einer Weise abbildet, die die Bildaufnahme prägt und offensichtlich darauf abzielt, diese Körperteile sexualisiert darzustellen”). The offence in question was thereby made more precise with regard to the sexualised depiction.

An effect on the outside world exists where corresponding content is made accessible to third parties. In the case of unauthorised production, it must be established that the sexualising content was created precisely without the consent of the person concerned. The general right of personality (allgemeines Persönlichkeitsrecht) under Article 1 in conjunction with Article 2(1) GG can already be seriously violated by the production of sexualised deepfakes. The risk that such an image or image content reaches third parties and is disseminated for their own purposes is inherent. An effect on the outside world therefore generally exists, even if the intensity of the interference is comparatively lower. In the view taken here, the construction of an endangerment offence, as proposed by the BRAK, would therefore go too far.

Freedom of Expression and the General Right of Personality

The law must also be consistent with freedom of expression under Article 5(1) GG. The scope of protection of freedom of expression may also cover the use of social networks for disseminating opinions. A court-ordered blocking of a user account can therefore constitute a considerable interference and falls within the scope of protection.

With regard to freedom of expression, however, it must be taken into account that polemical and exaggerated statements are in principle also protected. Abusive criticism (Schmähkritik), however, is not covered by the scope of protection where the defamation of a person, without any factual connection, is the main concern. The Federal Constitutional Court (Bundesverfassungsgericht) has thus emphasised that the individual should be able to decide for themselves how they wish to present themselves to third parties or to the public (BVerfGE 63, 131/142). This also means protection against statements that may have a negative effect on a person’s reputation (BVerfGE 152, 152/186).9 Against this background, the proposal to make criminal liability dependent on a concrete effect on the outside world is not necessarily conducive. In the case of sexualised depictions in particular, there is a special need for protection.

Article 5(1) GG is subject to the limits of Article 5(2) GG, which contains a so-called qualified statutory reservation (qualifizierter Gesetzesvorbehalt). Article 5(1) GG may thereby be restricted, among other things, by a general law. According to the prevailing combination formula (Kombinationsformel) of the Federal Constitutional Court, a law is general if it does not seek to prohibit a particular opinion but instead seeks to give effect to a legal interest of higher rank than freedom of expression in the individual case.

In the present case, it is precisely the right of personality under Article 1(1) in conjunction with Article 2(1) GG that is to be protected. This includes, in particular, the right to one’s own image, personal honour and the right to informational self-determination (Recht auf informationelle Selbstbestimmung). These legal positions may be impaired by the production and dissemination of corresponding deepfake videos. Insofar as the provisions merely permit an interference relating to opinions but do not prohibit a specific opinion, the protection of rights of personality speaks in favour of classifying them as general laws. In all other respects, the principle of proportionality must be observed.

At this point it should be noted that Section 184k(5) StGB-E provides for an exception for acts carried out in the exercise of overriding legitimate interests. These include, in particular, purposes of art, science, research, teaching, and reporting on current or historical events. This means that an exception must be recognised where interests protected by fundamental rights are correspondingly at stake.

Moreover, the dissemination of knowingly untrue facts may also satisfy the offence of defamation under Section 187 StGB. This may be the case, for example, where statements injurious to honour are knowingly and falsely attributed to a person and corresponding content is disseminated. The amendments envisaged within the framework of Section 184k StGB-E, by contrast, concern in particular sexualised image content.

Ultimately, not every unlawful impairment of the general right of personality warrants criminal punishment. In certain cases, measures by platform operators as well as civil-law claims can ensure sufficient protection. These include, in particular, claims for injunctive relief under Section 1004(1) sentence 2 of the German Civil Code (Bürgerliches Gesetzbuch, BGB) by analogy or liability in damages under Section 823(1) BGB. This differentiation corresponds to the legislature’s previous evaluation, according to which not every infringement of rights of personality is sanctioned under criminal law. The legislature has, however, already made certain serious violations of the intimate sphere and of the highly personal sphere of life punishable. The envisaged amendments to criminal law build on this existing system and correlate with the objective of the GgdG-E.

Secrecy of Telecommunications

The secrecy of telecommunications (Fernmeldegeheimnis) under Article 10 GG is affected by the envisaged provisions on disclosure of information in Section 2(1) GgdG-E. In this connection, the citation requirement (Zitiergebot) under Article 19(1) GG must be observed, according to which a law that restricts a basic right must name that basic right in the provision. A reference to Article 10 GG is provided for in the draft Act. Under Section 2 GgdG-E, service providers and providers of internet access services are to be obliged, under certain conditions, to disclose information on data. The disclosure of information is to be permissible only after a prior court order.

B. Outlook

The envisaged provisions illustrate the Federal Government’s endeavour to adapt protection against digital violence to ongoing technological development. The draft Act is now proceeding through the further legislative process. It remains to be seen whether the Bundestag will adopt the draft Act. Insofar as the consent of the Bundesrat is not constitutionally required, it is a bill not requiring the consent of the Bundesrat (Einspruchsgesetz) within the meaning of Article 77(3) GG. Accordingly, the Bundesrat may lodge an objection if it has demanded the convening of the Mediation Committee under Article 77(2) GG.

It will be decisive whether the legislature succeeds in striking an appropriate balance between the protection of the general right of personality and fundamental rights such as freedom of expression under Article 5(1) GG.


  1. Preeti/Kumar/Kumar Sharma, A GAN-Based Model of Deepfake Detection in Social Media, Procedia Computer Science, Procedia Computer Science 218 (2023), 2153, 2153. ↩︎

  2. Diel et al., The harm of deepfakes: a scoping review of deepfakes’ negative effects on human mind and behavior, AI & SOCIETY (2025), 5971, 5972, 5983. ↩︎

  3. See: Draft of an Act to Strengthen the Protection under Civil Law and Criminal Law against Digital Violence (Entwurf eines Gesetzes zur Stärkung des zivilrechtlichen und strafrechtlichen Schutzes vor digitaler Gewalt), available at: https://www.bmjv.de/SharedDocs/Downloads/DE/Gesetzgebung/RegE/RegE_GgdG.pdf?__blob=publicationFile&v=3 (last accessed on 14 October 2026). ↩︎

  4. The covert photographing underneath a person’s clothing. ↩︎

  5. Draft of an Act to Strengthen the Protection under Civil Law and Criminal Law against Digital Violence (Entwurf eines Gesetzes zur Stärkung des zivilrechtlichen und strafrechtlichen Schutzes vor digitaler Gewalt), available at: https://www.bmjv.de/SharedDocs/Downloads/DE/Gesetzgebung/RegE/RegE_GgdG.pdf?__blob=publicationFile&v=3, p. 12 f. (last accessed on 14 October 2026). ↩︎

  6. Draft of an Act to Strengthen the Protection under Civil Law and Criminal Law against Digital Violence (Entwurf eines Gesetzes zur Stärkung des zivilrechtlichen und strafrechtlichen Schutzes vor digitaler Gewalt), available at: https://www.bmjv.de/SharedDocs/Downloads/DE/Gesetzgebung/RegE/RegE_GgdG.pdf?__blob=publicationFile&v=3, p. 13 f. (last accessed on 14 October 2026). ↩︎

  7. Draft of an Act to Strengthen the Protection under Civil Law and Criminal Law against Digital Violence (Entwurf eines Gesetzes zur Stärkung des zivilrechtlichen und strafrechtlichen Schutzes vor digitaler Gewalt), available at: https://www.bmjv.de/SharedDocs/Downloads/DE/Gesetzgebung/RegE/RegE_GgdG.pdf?__blob=publicationFile&v=3, p. 1 f., p. 48 (last accessed on 14 October 2026). ↩︎

  8. https://www.brak.de/newsroom/newsletter/nachrichten-aus-berlin/2026/ausgabe-11-2026-v-2752026/gute-ziele-aber-viele-offene-fragen-brak-kritisiert-gesetzentwurf-gegen-digitale-gewalt/ (last accessed on 15 October 2026). ↩︎

  9. Cf. Draft of an Act to Strengthen the Protection under Civil Law and Criminal Law against Digital Violence (Entwurf eines Gesetzes zur Stärkung des zivilrechtlichen und strafrechtlichen Schutzes vor digitaler Gewalt), available at: https://www.bmjv.de/SharedDocs/Downloads/DE/Gesetzgebung/RegE/RegE_GgdG.pdf?__blob=publicationFile&v=3, p. 1 f., p. 68 (last accessed on 16 October 2026). ↩︎

Suggested citation

Zierhut, Annika S.: A Fundamental Legal Analysis of the Draft Act on Protection against Digital Violence, Zierhut Jura, October 8, 2026, https://zierhut-jura.de/en/artikel/a-fundamental-legal-analysis-of-the-draft-act-on-protection-against-digital-violence/.