← All articles

Even if a company can build an argument that is defensible under data protection law, not every legal risk is thereby eliminated. Recruiting scraping operates not only in the area of tension surrounding the GDPR (General Data Protection Regulation, Regulation (EU) 2016/679), but also in the area of platform rules, civil-law liability and possible claims for damages.

Platform Rules

Processing may theoretically appear defensible under data protection law and yet violate the rules of the platform. Conversely, a user interface made accessible by the platform does not automatically make data processing GDPR-compliant.

LinkedIn

In the case of LinkedIn, the contractual position is comparatively clear. In its terms of use, the platform expressly prohibits the use of software, scripts, robots, crawlers or comparable means to scrape or copy profiles or other data of the services.

For companies, this means: even if one still wishes to argue on data protection grounds, there remains the additional risk that accounts are blocked, access is restricted or contractual claims are triggered.

XING

According to section 10.2 of the general terms and conditions (AGB), XING’s services offer users the possibility of transmitting their personal data to other users or of revoking access to this data. This transmission takes place at the users’ own risk, so that responsibility on the part of the users is implied. Users must therefore reckon with the possibility that third parties may process this data. On XING as well, the public visibility of data does not give rise to an unrestricted right to further process it as one pleases. It is true that in business networks one must typically expect that professional profile data will be noticed and used. This does not, however, give rise to an unlimited power to collect data systematically and in an automated manner.

Anyone who processes large amounts of personal data in an automated manner on XING or similar services therefore remains fully within the scope of data protection and organisational duties of review.

Damages

For a long time, many proceedings disputed when data subjects can claim non-material damage for data protection infringements. The development of case law now clearly shows that companies should take this risk seriously.

Even the loss of control over personal data can become legally relevant. This increases the pressure on companies not only to have formally sound processes but also to implement technically and organisationally robust protective mechanisms.

The Problem of Accountability

It is precisely in a dispute that it becomes apparent why accountability is so important. Whoever processes personal data bears the burden of presentation and proof for the lawfulness of the processing.

The legal principle underlying Section 26 of the Federal Data Protection Act (Bundesdatenschutzgesetz, BDSG) likewise speaks in favour of such lawfulness: under it, personal data of employees may be processed for employment-related purposes where necessary for hiring decisions or, after hiring, for carrying out or terminating the employment contract or to exercise or satisfy rights and obligations of employees’ representation laid down by law or by collective agreements or other agreements between the employer and staff council.1 The legislator’s intention thus indicates here that the processing is permissible. The present situation is also comparable to that of a headhunter. The latter collects a not insignificant amount of data on various persons in order to find suitable employees.2 This approach, too, is generally regarded as unproblematic.3

Questions of copyright law may also play a role, for example in connection with database protection or the unauthorised appropriation of protected content. For pure recruiting scenarios with focused use of data, these questions are usually not in the foreground. Copyright remains unviolated as long as data is not passed off as one’s own or published as such on external websites. The permissibility of screen scraping in the context of copyright law depends on whether copyrights or database protection under Sections 87a et seq. of the Copyright Act (Urheberrechtsgesetz, UrhG) are infringed.4

Conclusion

Legally, recruiting scraping is not only a question of the GDPR. In addition, companies must reckon with platform violations, account restrictions and risks of damages claims.


  1. Similarly, a draft bill of the Bundestag (BT-Drs. 17/4230): Section 32(6) sentences 2 and 3 BDSGE: “If the employer has previously informed the employee of this, the employer may collect generally accessible data without the employee’s involvement […]” – Hoffmann, NZA 2022, 19 (20). ↩︎

  2. Cf. on this: ArbRAktuell 2017, 185. ↩︎

  3. Cf. ArbRAktuell 2017, 185. ↩︎

  4. LG Essen, judgment of 26.03.2009 - 4 O 69/09 – ITRB 2009, 124, 125. ↩︎

Suggested citation

Zierhut, Annika S.: Accountability and Platform Rules, Zierhut Jura, March 24, 2026, https://zierhut-jura.de/en/artikel/accountability-and-platform-rules/.