Even if recruiting scraping can be based on a legitimate interest in an individual case, the legal assessment is not yet complete. In practice, permissibility often fails not on the basic idea but on its implementation. Under the GDPR, it is indispensable that the specific processing is properly structured, limited and demonstrably controlled.
Data Minimisation: Do Not Collect Everything That Is Technically Accessible
The probably most important yardstick is: only as much as necessary, not as much as possible. According to the principle of data minimisation under Art. 5(1)(c) GDPR, or “limited to what is necessary”, the relevance and necessity of the data processing must be observed and it must be adequate in relation to the purpose.1 Companies may therefore not simply take over entire profiles into their systems merely because the data are visible or retrievable. Only what is actually needed for the specific recruiting purpose is necessary. Anyone who merely wishes to identify suitable candidates will hardly need the complete profile history, every activity, all interests or additional contextual information. The narrower the selection of data, the better the processing can be justified.
Purpose Limitation
A further core point is purpose limitation. Only a clearly defined, legitimate and documented purpose is permissible. For example:
- Identification of potentially suitable candidates for specific open positions
- Approaching candidates for particular professional fields of deployment
- Updating a narrow talent pool with a limited duration
It becomes problematic where data are later used for other aims without a new assessment, for example for sales, market analyses, profiling or general data enrichment.
Transparency: Data Subjects Must Not Be Left in the Dark
The principles enshrined in the GDPR are intended precisely to prevent individuals from no longer knowing which personal data are being processed. Transparency and information are therefore central requirements.
In the case of scraping from third-party sources, the question arises of the information obligations under Art. 14 GDPR. Companies must in principle inform about
- which data are processed,
- from which source they originate,
- for what purpose the processing takes place,
- on what legal basis it rests,
- how long the data are stored,
- which rights the data subjects have.
Although Art. 14 GDPR recognises exceptions, for instance where the provision of information is impossible or would involve a disproportionate effort, these exceptions are to be interpreted narrowly.2
Erasure and Storage Limitation: No Stockpile of Data
A particularly critical point in scraping is the storage period. Many processes fail because data are collected but no proper mechanism exists for when they are erased again. Personal data may be stored only for as long as is necessary for the respective purpose. Thereafter, they must be erased or at least removed from active processes.
For practice, this means:
- Clear retention periods are needed.
- Technical erasure mechanisms are needed.
An example: a possible candidate definitively no longer comes into consideration for a specific position. From that point onwards, it must be examined whether and for how long further storage can still be justified.3
Right to Object and Data Subject Rights
Anyone who processes data on the basis of a legitimate interest must take the right to object under Art. 21 GDPR seriously. Data subjects must have the possibility of objecting to the processing of their data. Likewise, companies must be organisationally able to implement further rights, in particular:
- Access
- Rectification
- Erasure
- Restriction of processing
Is a Data Protection Impact Assessment Needed?
Not every recruiting process automatically triggers a data protection impact assessment. It may, however, become necessary if processing is likely to result in a high risk to the rights and freedoms of natural persons.
This is particularly relevant in the case of:
- systematic and extensive evaluation of personal aspects,
- automated profiling,
- large-scale linking of several data sources,
- permanent or very intensive monitoring.
Anyone who, by contrast, collects data only to a limited extent, identifies candidates only roughly and creates no in-depth personality profiles is more likely to remain below this threshold. This too, however, should be consciously examined and documented.
Accountability: Without Documentation, It Becomes Dangerous
The GDPR requires not only conduct in compliance with data protection but also proof of it. In case of doubt, companies must therefore be able to demonstrate
- why they process the data,
- why the scope is necessary,
- how the balancing was carried out,
- which periods apply,
- which protective measures have been implemented,
- how the rights of the data subjects are safeguarded in practice.
Conclusion
In recruiting scraping, what really matters is often not only the legal basis but the actual obligations under data protection law. Data minimisation, transparency, erasure and accountability form part of the foundation of lawfulness.
BeckOK DatenschutzR/Schantz, 48th ed. 1 November 2021, DSGVO, Art. 5 para. 25. ↩︎
In its Census Judgment (Volkszählungs-Urteil), the BVerfG already described the information asymmetry resulting from the opacity of data processing and the resulting uncertainty […]. A social order, and a legal order enabling it, in which citizens can no longer know who knows what about them on what occasion, would not be compatible with the right to informational self-determination (BVerfGE 65, 1 (43) = NJW 1984, 419), cf. on this (BeckOK DatenschutzR/Schantz, 48th ed. 1 November 2021, DS-GVO Art. 5 para. 10). ↩︎
Following a decision of the BAG: BAG, judgment of 29 June 2017 – 8 AZR 402/15 (LAG Hessen 15 June 2015 – 16 Sa 1619/14), BeckRS 2017, 132031. ↩︎
Zierhut, Annika S.: Data Minimisation, Transparency, Erasure, Zierhut Jura, March 22, 2026, https://zierhut-jura.de/en/artikel/data-minimisation-transparency-erasure/.