← All articles

The Core Problem

Where nothing has yet been paid out under a life insurance policy, the assumption of damage initially seems implausible. After all, the insurance company has not paid out any money at that point. For precisely this reason, the question of pecuniary damage (Vermögensschaden) is among the more complex problems of fraud at the conclusion of the contract (Eingehungsbetrug).

The question is nevertheless justified: can damage arise merely because a contract comes into being that is based on deception from the outset?

The Concept of Damage in Fraud at the Conclusion of the Contract

In principle, damage is determined by means of the principle of balancing (Saldierungsprinzip), taking the difference hypothesis into account. The prevailing view is the economic concept of assets, according to which assets are the sum of all goods having monetary value less liabilities, irrespective of their legal recognition. In Eingehungsbetrug, the examination does not simply ask in the abstract whether someone has behaved dishonestly.1

In a case of Eingehungsbetrug, performance and counter-performance must therefore be compared. Damage exists where the claim acquired is not equivalent in value to the obligation assumed in return.2

Aleatory Reciprocal (Synallagmatic) Structure of the Life Insurance Contract

Under a life insurance contract, the policyholder, within the meaning of Section 1 sentence 2 of the Insurance Contract Act (Versicherungsvertragsgesetz, VVG), in principle pays the respective insurance premium. In return, the policyholder receives the assumption of the risk of death within the meaning of Section 1 sentence 1 VVG (insurance cover) and a related claim to payment of the sum insured. Admittedly, the amount of the premium payment will always differ in the individual case owing to differing circumstances of the policyholders.3

Shift of the Risk

The Federal Court of Justice (Bundesgerichtshof, BGH) assumed that fraud at the conclusion of the contract is at least a possibility, even though the appellate court on points of law could not make an assessment in the abstract. What must be assessed are “on the one hand, the economic value of the claim to payment of the insurance premiums and, on the other hand, the economic value of the risk cover.4 The damage is therefore rather to be seen in the circumstance that the insurer obtains a claim to premiums that is no longer economically equivalent to the obligation it has assumed. The relationship between performance and counter-performance thus shifts at the very moment the contract is concluded.

Harm by Endangerment

This is where the construct of harm by endangerment (Gefährdungsschaden) comes into play. It refers to a situation in which the victim’s assets have not yet been definitively damaged but are already concretely endangered in economic terms.

According to the legal construct of an “endangerment of assets equivalent to damage” (schadensgleiche Vermögensgefährdung), also called “damage-establishing” endangerment of assets, a pecuniary damage is assumed where the endangerment is so concrete that it can materialise at any time without further action and the victim can no longer avoid the occurrence of the damage, so that a certain degree of endangerment is reached.5

In its more recent case law on the life insurance contract, the BGH no longer uses this legal construct by name. In that respect it is recognised in case law and forms the basis of the institution of Eingehungsbetrug. However, a strict interpretation is required in order to avoid a violation of the principle of specificity under Article 103(2) of the Basic Law (Grundgesetz, GG).6

Benchmarks for Determining the Damage

An existing problem, apparent in both case law and the literature, is that there are no generally established benchmarks for determining the damage in the case of a life insurance contract.

Willingness and Ability to Pay

A first role is played by whether the policyholder is willing and able to pay the premiums in accordance with the contract at all. The emphasis lies on the offender’s obligation, which is significant within the framework of the reciprocal relationship (Synallagma) in Eingehungsbetrug. An evaluation of the deception is therefore used.

The Probability of Successful Execution of the Criminal Plan

In addition, the probability of successful execution of the criminal plan is said to be relevant. This involves a multi-stage course of events planned by the offender. A probability of the later payout of the sum insured can, on the one hand, influence the determination of the pecuniary damage, namely with regard to possible probabilities of loss. The probability that the plan can actually be carried out may well influence the economic risk.7

Several Insurance Policies Taken Out in Parallel

Whoever takes out several life insurance policies at the same time typically increases the economic endangerment, since the possible total damage grows as a result. Such multiple conclusions can likewise be an indicator for calculating a minimum damage.8

The Insurer’s Safeguards

Verification mechanisms on the part of the insurer also play a role. If considerable control steps are still carried out before a payout, this can reduce the risk. It must be noted that such mechanisms elude an economic assessment and can, in any event, only be an indicator of the degree of endangerment.

Concrete Determination of the Damage

It is precisely at this point that the greatest difficulty becomes apparent. The damage cannot be determined so easily. That does not mean, however, that damage is ruled out. Criminal law does not demand mathematical perfection. It does, however, demand a sustainable economic justification.

The assumption is therefore convincing that at least minimum damage (Mindestschaden) can be established or estimated if it is clear that the insurer has assumed an increased risk foreign to the contract without receiving an equivalent counter-performance for it. In any event, a quantification appropriate to the individual case or a sustainable estimate must be made.9

Civil-Law Claims as Compensation

Civil-law remedies might, moreover, speak against affirming pecuniary damage at the conclusion of the contract. The insurer regularly has claims for damages under Sections 823(2) and 826 of the Civil Code (Bürgerliches Gesetzbuch, BGB), claims for unjust enrichment under Sections 812 et seq. BGB, or claims arising from culpa in contrahendo (Section 311(2) no. 1 BGB in conjunction with Section 241(2) BGB).10

In favour of sufficient compensation through such civil-law claims, it can be argued that criminal law is, in terms of its dogmatics, precisely an accessory protective body of law and regularly draws on civil-law and public-law standards.11 Such a purely normative view, however, runs counter to the basis of an economic view and cannot provide compensation where these claims are available to the victim precisely because of the deception.12

Consistency of the Judgment

The BGH carries out an examination of the individual case. The BGH expressly assumes Eingehungsbetrug only if, taking the circumstances into account, an economic reduction in the value of the counter-performance can be established.13 With regard to the concreteness of the harm by endangerment, it can be argued that a fixed premium payment and a corresponding cover of the risk of the occurrence of the condition have already been agreed. In the view taken here, the danger is sufficiently concrete.


  1. Kindhäuser/Böse, StR BT II, § 27 para. 63.; Kölbel, in: Achenbach/Ransiek/Rönnau, Handbuch WStR, 5. Teil, 1. Kapitel, para. 99; Satzger/Schluckebier/Widmaier StGB/Satzger, § 263 para. 148; case law since RGSt 44, 230; cf. Rengier, StR BT I, § 13 paras. 140, 142. ↩︎

  2. Fischer, StGB, § 263 para. 176; Jahn, JuS 2012, p. 266 (267). ↩︎

  3. Cf. Lindenau, Die Betrugsstrafbarkeit des Versicherungsnehmers aus strafrechtlicher und kriminologischer Sicht, pp. 229, 231; Krey/Hellmann/Heinrich, StR BT, § 13 para. 746. ↩︎

  4. BGH, judgment of 8 December 2021 – 5 StR 236/21 – juris, para. 20. ↩︎

  5. Kindhäuser/Böse, StR BT II, § 27 para. 96; Kölbel, in: Achenbach/Ransiek/Rönnau, Handbuch WStR, 5. Teil, 1. Kapitel, para. 116; Steinsiek/Vollmer, ZIS 2012, p. 586 (589). ↩︎

  6. BGHSt 34, 394 (para. 395); 53; 199 (para. 202); the Prussian Supreme Tribunal (Preußisches Obertribunal) recognised the legal construct very early: R 8, 238 f.; BVerfGE 130, 1 (para. 48); Jahn, JuS 2012, p. 266 (267). ↩︎

  7. Thielmann/Groß-Bölting/Strauß, HRRS 2010, p. 39 (43). ↩︎

  8. Funck, Täuschungsbedingter Betrugsschaden, p. 424. ↩︎

  9. BVerfGE 130, 1 (para. 178); cf. also BGH, HRRS 2013, no. 191, para. 36; Schiemann, NJW 2013, p. 888 (888). ↩︎

  10. BGH, NJW 2009, p. 3448 (3465); Wessels/Hillenkamp/Schuhr, StR BT 2, § 13 para. 578. ↩︎

  11. Cf. Denga, JA 2018, p. 833 (834). ↩︎

  12. LK/Tiedemann, § 263 para. 166; S/S/Perron, § 263 para. 120; Wessels/Hillenkamp/Schuhr, StR BT 2, § 13 para. 578; Krey/Hellmann/Heinrich, StR BT, § 11 para. 706; cf. Schladitz, wistra 2022, p. 108 (112); Denga, JA 2018, p. 833 (836-837). ↩︎

  13. Cf. BGH, judgment of 8 December 2021 – 5 StR 236/21 – juris, para. 22. ↩︎

Suggested citation

Zierhut, Annika S.: Pecuniary Damage in Fraud at the Conclusion of the Contract, Zierhut Jura, March 12, 2026, https://zierhut-jura.de/en/artikel/pecuniary-damage-in-fraud-at-the-conclusion-of-the-contract/.